Hacker RealtimeBuilt with Neon Realtime
connecting… · checking source…

Comment on Hacker News

  1. > Also, the NT kernel is criminally underrated, and pretty much unknown to hobbyists. It had features that Linux took years and years to come up with its own design for...

    A person after my own heart. NT was actually designed, versus being a reimplementation of an existing thing.

    reply
  2. Hard file locking makes Windows Update into agony.

    I can see the 70s motivation for it, but it is a terrible burden in modern times.

    Hopefully is is not implemented here.

    reply
  3. Kudos for not being another UNIX clone.

    However Windows NT originally was already POSIXy, what it lacked all these years was Microsoft being serious about POSIX subsystem, had that been the case, probably Linux would never taken off among PC, the same experience as OS X would be there in 1993.

    reply
  4. I was looking for that line:

    > The contract is that the syscalls and low-level interfaces match those of NT, but not the daemons or how the kernel itself is structured. This is in contrast to what ReactOS aims to do, which is an exact recreation of Windows.

    reply
  5. So.. Why NT? Is it fast? Is it secure? Does it allow modern features? Is it hackable? Or why?
    reply
  6. > None of the substantive code was written by AI.

    That is impressive

    reply
  7. IMHO this is one of the OSes with the weirdest decisions I've seen on here. I do agree with using PE instead of ELF, as the dynamic linking situation of the latter (and Unix-likes in general) is, to put it bluntly, a horrid mess.

    The POSIX functions are split over ucrtbase, iphlpapi, and ws2_32, as on Windows, with anything that Windows doesn't implement put in mnposix.

    LOL. POSIX in ucrtbase! Those are words that I never expected to see together.

    I used AI to help with the mechanical parts of porting

    I feel like it won't be long before someone comes up with a crazy chimera of an OS that can run DOS, Windows, Linux, BSD, and macOS binaries. It doesn't look like AI is replacing software developers, but rather boosting them quite significantly; there seems to be a lot of activity and new projects I've seen recently from many who aren't even using AI themselves, but must be somehow being inspired by others to do more.

    reply